Yara Mekawei, "Sonic Forces", CTM Festival 2025, silent green, photo: Udo Siegfriedt

On Hearing Voices

Yara Mekawei & Saadet Türköz / Eldar Tagi at CTM Festival 2025

Samuel Hertz25.02.2025review, Issue 01

The evening’s program of Yara Mekawei’s “Sonic Forces” and the collaboration between Saadet Türköz and Eldar Tagi at CTM coalesces around power, agency, and the potential of the voice as a force that breaks through, that transgresses, skips, stutters, and growls through space and time.

The geographer and sound-artist AM Kanngieser writes that “dynamics of power and how we relate to one another find an articulation through the voice, they shape the voice… The inflections and modulations of the voice contain forces that we must become more conscious of.”1 Not only are these socio-cultural dynamics expressed through language, but there is an affective element to the sound of the voice that embodies both violence and care. Both separation and belonging. How, then, might one hear and attend to (these) voices?

Yara Mekawei’s “Sonic Forces” begins the evening with several vocal settings that waver above immaculately designed sound environments. Sharp, crystalline textures emerge from thrumming, noisy environments resembling the experience of standing under a busy concrete highway. In other moments, pops and crackles slither around the room, yielding to the texture of a harmonium beating away in the background. In all cases, these environments serve as transportational settings for the voices that surface to take center stage. Mekawei works primarily with vocal recordings collected “in villages along Egypt’s borders with Libya, Palestine/Israel, and Sudan (…) shaped by long-standing familial and cultural connections that transcend national borders, with intermarriage and shared traditions forming a strong social fabric.”2 Importantly, as Mekawei later tells me, these national borders reassert themselves through ongoing war and the economic, agricultural, cultural, and societal violence that force migration to these neighboring countries.

Yara Mekawei, "Sonic Forces", CTM Festival 2025, silent green, photo: Udo Siegfriedt

In the echoing, doubling, and delays of the voices rebounding across the room, the despair of waiting and wondering becomes palpable. The “diversity of dialects” amplifies the chaos of these border zones as the voices swarm and merge—repeating in a minimalist frenzy that is at once overwhelming yet causes one to sense the distinct timbre, lilt, and cadence of each of these speakers. These echoes, these doublings, are a strategy for Mekawei: they allow one’s voice to travel, even when one’s body is prevented from doing so. At times, they appear in two places at once; I imagine the voice as breaking through these border zones, straddling barriers, in a quantum-doubled state of mourning and reassurance. Of terror and hope. The voices enrapture through these stuttering and expanding articulations that seem to tunnel through the noise and carve out a space of refuge, despite the potential unfamiliarity of the language. The delays of the voice open a third space, a zone of the in-between. These spaces may be exemplified by the (in)distinct violence of the border zones, but also by the powerful third space of affection and solidarity that is opened when these voices meet and amplify each other and are amplified by Mekawei’s composed settings.

As a hushed whispering decelerates the dense textures of the work, Mekawei takes the microphone to read a passage from “Fusûs al-Hikam” (“The Bezels of Wisdom”) by Ibn Arabi about “the intricate relationship between human perception and transcendent knowledge.”3 The echoing of the previous voices remains present, allowing me to inhabit the third space opened by her voice. The echo, the double that passes between my ears, illustrates the multiplicities of affective belonging, and likewise, the terror of finding oneself displaced—split into multiples.

Yara Mekawei, "Sonic Forces", CTM Festival 2025, silent green, photo: Udo Siegfriedt

Contrasting with Mekawei’s dense and complex environments, Eldar Tagi’s sparse, skeletal, pizzicato guitar and daxophone instrumentation creeps in slowly and lays the groundwork for a raw, evocative, and powerful set with vocalist Saadet Türköz, in their premiere collaboration. We are reseated in the round, an opening poem from Nâzım Hikmet gives way to Türköz’s ensnaring voice that stutters, growls, soothes, and breaks across the space. The sound shudders off the walls through amplification, yet at times, Türköz blissfully ignores the microphone, opting instead to meet the gaze of the audience directly with her voice. Türköz and Tagi guide us through an expansive garden of articulations, bundling us in the suspense of sentences or phrases that never seem to end. They expand, wrapping us in language that deconstructs and reforms as syllables congregate and tremble among winding harmonies.

Türköz informs me that her practice of interweaving text and polyvocality derives from the Kazakh tradition of spontaneous lyrical improvisation: songs, lyrics and phrases are all dreamt into being in real-time to celebrate, or to mourn. To remember and to memorialize. Mid-performance, she is inspired to recite a personal text about a Kazakh horseman preparing for his death. The horseman knowing however that his knowledge and training have been passed on to his children through generational vocality, he can die in peace. For Türköz, the performance space as well is inseparable from the flood of lyrics that pass through her—the Kuppelhalle as a former cremation site fills her with a need to acknowledge those whose bodies have drifted through this space. Türköz turns to Tagi and remarks, mid-song:

“I want to tell you many things about people who have no roof over their heads, who have had their homes and cultural assets stolen, and who have lost their lives under unjust systems. Well, it all goes on because we want to believe that ethical rightness remains desirable forever. We'll keep at it.”4

Here, Türköz accompanies the voices of Mekawei: these voices breathe space into the precarity of lives on the edge. Voices that hand down generational stories, that make maps of space where memories live between bodies and across border zones. I hear multiple sobs, someone in the audience cries softly above me. The voice’s characters are many, and now seem to populate the space, to appear alongside the audience as well, in all their multiplicities. The stretching and clattering of both Tagi and Türköz’s instruments work as a seamless pair yet resist the urge to be woven together. Instead, these ruptures encourage to mingle among stories fragmented by lost, forgotten, or destroyed histories—to hear with voices.

Saadet Türköz & Eldar Tagi, CTM Festival 2025, silent green, photo: Udo Siegfriedt

A sincere thank you to Yara Mekawei and Saadet Türköz for their generous responses to my post-concert questions. Türköz’s quotes are translated from German.

Samuel Hertz (he/him) is a composer and researcher in Sonic Geographies: Centre for GeoHumanities and based in Berlin.

Saadet Türköz, CTM Festival 2025, silent green, photo: Udo Siegfriedt

CTM Festival 2025
Artists: Yara Mekawei, Saadet Türköz & Eldar Tagi
Date: 25/01/2025, 18.00
Location: silent green Kulturquartier, Berlin

00:00-00:00
  • Hanne Lippard, Homework, Talk Shop, 2024

    review

  • Amina Abbas-Nazari, Polyphonic Embodiments: Materials

    Article (Issue 01)

  • Giulia Deval, Audio Excerpts from Pitch

    Article (Issue 01)

  • Luïza Luz, Thunder, Music for Wild Angels

    Article (Issue 01)

  • Anna Bromley, No2 How Katrina Krasniqi almost gets lost

    Article (Issue 01)